Vitruvius – Book V

In Book V, Vitruvius applied Pythagorean principles of harmonic ratios in the design of theatres. He implemented a “room equalization system” based on bronze or earthen vessels – called “echea”placed under the seats of theatres, to assist, by their resonance, the voices of the performers.

This is one of the first examples of an enclosed space conceived as a musical instrument where its design features are intended to enhance specific sounds that take place within it. The Vitruvian theaters interact with the performers, amplifying and “equalizing” the sounds of their on-stage performances. In figure 2-2 we can clearly appreciate that the tuning of the room is not indifferent to its design; small and large theaters were tuned differently.

“The harmonies that human nature can measure out are called symphoniae in Greek, and number six: diastesseron (fourth), diapente (fifth), diapason (octave), and disdiatesseron (octave + fourth), disdiapente  (octave + fifth) and disdiapason (double octave).“In theaters, likewise, the bronze vessels – the ones the Greeks call echea – which are enclosed underneath the seats, are placed according to mathematical principle based on their pitch. The vessels are grouped in sections around the circle of the theater to create intervals of a fourth, a fifth and so on up to a double octave. As a result, the speaker, as it occurs onstage, should be so located in the theater’s overall design that when it strikes the echea it will be amplified on impact, reaching the ears of the spectators as a clearer and more pleasant sound.”

        Picture 3

Tuning system for the vessels.

The vessel tuning suggested by Vitruvius follows the progression of the first four partials after a fundamental tone, which are also separated by a fifth, a fourth and the resulting double octave. By reinforcing the first partials of an implied fundamental he provided the space with a characteristic resonance. Like in brass instruments, that “theoretical fundamental” is the lowest possible resonance that can be obtained from an instrument – in this case an enclosed space – related to its size and length of the sound waves. That resonance is not aurally present but it is the basis for the harmonic series. Vitruvius’ design follows that same principle, using the vessels tuned to the first partials of a harmonic series to provide the space with a particular formant. However that approach depends almost exclusively on the richness of the spectrum of the sound performed on-stage. The pure tone of a lyre would rarely provide enough spectral energy to stimulate the vibration of the vessels and – on the other hand – a strong baritone voice would take true advantage of them.  Following a basic acoustical principle, the Vitruvian vessels can reinforce properties already existing in a sound source but they are unable to generate them as there is no acoustical design capable of filling frequency “holes”. “Indeed, we can observe this from performers who sing to the lyre, who, when they want to sing in a higher key, turn toward the stage doors and thus avail themselves of the harmonic support that these can provide for their voices. When, however, theaters are constructed of more solid material, that is, of masonry, stone, or marble, which can not resonate, then they should be outfitted with echea for just that reason.”

Picture 2

Theater ceiling and audience area suggested by Vitruvius.

It is clear that the Roman master was foreseeing two core acoustical issues of theater design: reinforcement of sounds events happening on-stage and the frequency response of the space. His solution came from a combination between the steep angle of the audience seats and the design of the ceiling (sound reinforcement) and the resonating vessels system (frequency response). “By this contrivance the voice onstage, poured forth from stage – as it were, from the center of the theater – and circling outward, strikes the hollows of the individual vessels on contact, stirring up an increased clarity and a harmonic complement to its own tone.”

Vitruvius was already considering in his designs the quality of the sound perceived by the audience in a theater. He sought for a “clear and pleasant sound” with the desire to provide every member of the audience with the same aural experience. Those concerns are very much current today when la­rge audiences are the norm. In the design of theaters, aural architects have to simultaneously deal with the general acoustic properties of the space and their perception, reassuring that they propagate evenly throughout the audience area.  Parameters of balance, warmth, brightness and clarity are of standard use by architects in order to measure the desirable qualities of a space designed for performance. The aural pleasure of the audience was Vitruvius’s ultimate desire. Sound was his main concern in theatre design, and he strived to achieve an “ideal sound” that would please the audience members. Vitruvius translated the general harmonic proportions of sound into theater design. In other words, he made a theater a “tuned resonant body”.

CD review – I had to do it

BREATHLESS – KENNY G – ARISTA 07822-18646-2

Almost two decades ago, my girlfriend at the time came to me and said (I remember this literally) “I bought you a CD by this renowned clarinetist that I know you’ll love”. She gave me Breathless by Kenny G, and I immediately knew that it wouldn’t last much longer.

Breathless was the saxman’s sixth CD production, which became a music bestseller. The record travels the fine aesthetic line between pop music and smooth jazz, being neither of them. In Breathless, all the tunes combine the lightness of smooth jazz, with the predictability of pop. As a listener you always seem to know what is going to happen, and that is what eventually happens. The songs The joy of life, Forever in love, In the rain and Sentimental are shallow and unsurprising. Despite that, G does a technically acceptable job with the drums’ sequences, but while listening to the CD I started questioning the automatic playing of the sax. Was G just cruising through the melodies with his honey making single reed wand? This over abundance of well-known licks is unenchanting, and that is how it sounds: obvious and safe. Speaking of taking chances through a record, did you know that that same year (1992) Wynton Marsalis released Citi Movement, Joe Lovano Universal Language and Nirvana their Hormoaning?

However, I have to admit that the song G bop created some expectations (mainly for its title) which only lasted until I listened to it, nothing about bop, nor in the key of G, all about Kenneth Gorelick’s manufactured emotions. By the time this night is over could have been the least anticlimactic cut of the album. We heard Peabo Bryson’s lead voice in timeless versions of Disney movies’ songs. He is the one who sings along with Celine Dion in The beauty and the beast and in A whole new world, from Aladdin to name a few. Bryson’s participation couldn’t emerge from an ocean of commonalities. The song follows the recipe of every cloying love song, with extra cheesy saxophone fill-ins.

Needless to say, my relationship was over that night…

Uniform, interchangeable melodies in 4/4, almost at the same tempo, make a fair summary of this record. In the 20’s Eric Satie purposely wrote “furniture music” or ‘music not to be listened’, in the 90’s G wrote almost seventy minutes of it without even realizing. I can recommend this album; it is a must if you are fond of fungible music.

Disclaimer: this article was an “audition” review for a publication for which I work at the moment. Visit the Fanfare magazine archive to read my most recent work.

Charlie Markov: an algorithmic approach to the style of Charlie Parker

The Spanish version of this work will be published in the next edition of Sonic Ideas by the CMMAS, in Morelia, Mexico. Check it out!

Abstract

The present work is based on the hypothesis that the improvisational style of saxophonist Charlie Parker is condensed in the first chorus of his solo in his tune Confirmation. In order to verify this initial question, the study proposes a series of probabilistic analysis from the solo that are integrated in an algorithm in SuperCollider as a Markov chain of the first order.

Contact me if you want the full version of the paper. This research was presented at the North American Saxophone Alliance Conference in Minot State University in April.

Screen shot 2013-05-26 at 10.42.12 AM

Thank you!